← Insights

AI Products & Workflows

How to Judge an AI-Generated Design

Evaluate a design at the point of use, where the user needs to make a decision.

Imagine a restaurant owner asking AI to make a menu. The result has consistent type and colours. At lunch, people stand in a queue, looking for a set meal they can choose quickly. The price is too small to read from where they stand, and the meal the restaurant wants to feature gets lost among the other options.

The owner might struggle to explain which typeface or spacing would work better. They can still point out that customers need to read the price from a few steps away. They know which decision customers are trying to make, what they should notice first, and what happens when they cannot find it. Those are design judgments with consequences you can observe.

I find the word “taste” too broad for this conversation. It can refer to craft choices such as typography and composition. It can also refer to knowing what a particular situation calls for. The two kinds of judgment meet when the menu reaches the queue. I would give AI the details of that scene, let it propose layouts, and judge the result from where the customer stands. That gives me a clearer test than asking for a more polished menu.